How to Balance Homemade and Commercial Dog Food Safely

Kristina Voltin
4 days ago
5 min read

When it comes to feeding our beloved pets, the choices can often feel overwhelming. Should you stick with commercial pet food or venture into homemade meals for your dog? And if you choose a balance of both, how do you ensure nutritional needs are met? Dr. Susan Ricker, a veterinarian with extensive experience in integrative pet nutrition, delves into these questions, sharing her journey and expertise on how to make informed choices for your pet’s health.

This article synthesizes key insights from Dr. Ricker’s conversation on pet nutrition, highlighting her guidance on fresh feeding, nutrient balance, and the evolving role of pet owners in their pets' diets.

The Evolution of Pet Nutrition: Dr. Ricker's Journey

Dr. Ricker’s career began with a traditional veterinary education and practice, where nutrition training was heavily focused on ultra-processed commercial pet foods. However, her perspective shifted when she became a mother. Caring deeply about the nutrition and health of her children led her to question the same principles for her pets. This realization sparked her interest in fresh feeding - introducing wholesome, minimally processed foods into pet diets.

Her dissatisfaction with conventional treatment outcomes also drove her toward integrative approaches, such as veterinary spinal manipulation therapy. This journey expanded her understanding of the interconnectedness between food, health, and disease, both in humans and animals. Over the years, Dr. Ricker has become a champion of fresh feeding, nutrient balance, and evidence-based pet nutrition.

Fresh Feeding Basics: Why It Matters and How to Start

One of the key messages from Dr. Ricker is the importance of incorporating fresh, whole foods into your dog’s diet. She emphasizes that any step toward adding fresh, minimally processed ingredients is a positive move, even if you’re starting small. However, she also underscores the significance of complete and balanced nutrition to avoid nutrient deficiencies that can lead to chronic health problems.

Why Fresh Food?

Fresh foods often come with a matrix of nutrients and co-nutrients that work synergistically to support health. Unlike synthetic supplements added to processed pet foods, these nutrients are more bioavailable and work in harmony with the body.

Dr. Ricker shares that while rotating fresh food options can be beneficial, it’s essential to ensure that the diet consistently meets minimum nutrient requirements. She notes that nutrient deficiencies in dogs fed homemade or partial homemade diets often include magnesium, potassium, manganese, iodine, vitamin D, vitamin E, and omega-3 fatty acids like EPA and DHA. Addressing these can significantly enhance your dog’s overall health and quality of life.

Understanding Nutrient Balance: The Spreadsheet vs. "Wing-It" Debate

Dr. Ricker explains that pet owners often fall into two camps when it comes to homemade pet food: those who meticulously spreadsheet every meal and those who take a more relaxed, "wing-it" approach. While she acknowledges the appeal of the latter, her experience has shown that nutrient imbalances can arise without careful planning.

Human diets, for example, are rarely perfect. When Dr. Ricker analyzed her own diet using a nutrient spreadsheet, she discovered consistent deficiencies, even though she ate a wide variety of whole foods. This realization strengthened her belief that calculating nutrient levels is essential when feeding pets, especially since dogs and cats have different nutritional needs than humans.

The Pitfalls of "Winging It"

Rotating ingredients without a plan can lead to deficiencies in critical nutrients like vitamin E, choline, or manganese. For example, if you rotate between foods that are all low in certain nutrients, your pet may suffer from persistent deficiencies despite the variety. While fresh feeding doesn’t have to be overly complicated, using tools or guides can help ensure a balanced approach.

The Role of Commercial Foods: A Starting Point, Not the End

Many pet owners rely on commercial pet foods, but Dr. Ricker highlights a major gap in how these products are formulated. Most commercial diets, even premium brands, are designed to meet the nutritional needs of highly active animals - like working dogs or outdoor cats in cold climates. However, the majority of pets in the U.S. are moderately to highly inactive, meaning they require fewer calories but still need sufficient nutrients.

The Calorie-Nutrient Problem

Commercial pet foods often fail to address the interplay between calorie intake and nutrient density. For example, if a dog eats less of a calorie-dense kibble to maintain a healthy weight, they may not receive the full profile of essential nutrients. This issue becomes especially problematic when veterinarians advise pet owners to simply feed less of a food without considering potential nutrient deficiencies.

Adding to Commercial Diets

Dr. Ricker suggests that pet owners can enhance commercial diets by adding fresh, nutrient-dense whole foods. A simple addition, such as a sardine for omega-3s or an egg yolk for choline, can make a significant difference in your dog’s health. These supplements not only fill nutritional gaps but also introduce variety and enrich your pet’s mealtime experience.

Tools for Formulating Balanced Diets: How Animal Diet Formulator Helps

For pet parents and professionals alike, tools like the Animal Diet Formulator (ADF) can simplify the process of creating balanced meals. ADF allows users to:

Formulate homemade diets using fresh ingredients.
Analyze the nutrient content of commercial foods and identify deficiencies.
Create hybrid diets that combine commercial products with fresh food additions.

Dr. Ricker recommends using ADF to customize diets based on your pet’s activity level and specific health needs. The tool supports multiple nutrient standards (AAFCO, FEDIAF, NRC), allowing users to tailor formulations for optimal results.

Fiber and Gut Health: An Often Overlooked Component

Dr. Ricker highlights the importance of fiber for both dogs and cats. Fiber supports gastrointestinal health, aids in nutrient absorption, and promotes regular digestion. While fresh prey diets can provide insoluble fiber (e.g., fur and feathers), soluble fiber from fruits and vegetables is crucial for feeding gut microbes and maintaining overall health.

Obligate carnivores like cats may require less fiber than dogs, but they still benefit from small amounts of plant-based fiber. Incorporating a mix of fermentable and insoluble fibers can significantly improve your pet’s gut health.

Key Takeaways

Fresh Food First: Adding fresh, whole foods to your pet’s diet is always a positive step. Start small and build from there.
Complete and Balanced is Key: Ensure that your pet’s diet meets all essential nutrient requirements. Nutrient deficiencies can lead to chronic health problems over time.
Analyze Commercial Foods: Most commercial diets are geared toward highly active pets. For less active pets, consider supplementation or hybrid diets.
Use Tools for Precision: Tools like Animal Diet Formulator can simplify the process of creating balanced diets, whether homemade, commercial, or hybrid.
Watch for Common Deficiencies: Magnesium, manganese, iodine, vitamin E, and omega-3 fatty acids are common gaps in homemade and commercial diets.
Incorporate Fiber: Both dogs and cats benefit from a mix of soluble and insoluble fibers for optimal digestive health.
Think Beyond the Label: Claims like "natural" on pet food products are often vague. Focus on transparency and nutrient profiles instead.

Closing Thoughts

Feeding your dog or cat is about more than just filling a bowl - it’s about nourishing their body to promote long-term health. Whether you prefer homemade meals, commercial diets, or a combination of both, the key to success lies in understanding nutrient balance and making informed choices. By incorporating fresh ingredients, monitoring nutrient levels, and leveraging tools like the Animal Diet Formulator, you can provide your pet with the best possible nutrition. After all, a healthy diet is the foundation of a happy, vibrant life for your furry companion.

Source: "Homemade vs Commercial Dog Food What You’re Getting Wrong with Dr Susan Recker" - The Pet Parenting Reset, YouTube, Oct 28, 2025 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2oDFf38fqQM